Episode 56: Two Graves and A Diary - Thrill Killer Alyssa Bustamante, part I

"Was it just because you wanted to know how it felt to kill someone?”

In the small town of St. Martins, Missouri, when a nine-year-old girl vanishes, the entire community comes together to search for her. While investigators combed through the vast woods where it was believed she had last been, they discovered two small graves. The disturbing words found inside a teenager’s diary would lead homicide detectives to a shocking and very unusual suspect. This is the tragic and disturbing case of child killer Alyssa Bustamante and her victim, Elizabeth Olten.

Content Warnings: Child Homicide, Suicidal Ideation, Depression

Key Themes: Psychopathy, Female Offenders, Teenage Killers, Criminal Investigation, Forensics

Resources:

IF YOU OR SOMEONE YOU KNOW IS SUFFERING FROM DEPRESSION OR SUBSTANCE ABUSE, OR YOU THINK SOMEONE MAY BE A VICTIM OF CHILD ABUSE, PLEASE REACH OUT FOR HELP.

988 SUICIDE & CRISIS HOTLINE: YOU CAN CALL OR TEXT 988 24/7, AND LEARN ABOUT RESOURCES AT 988LIFELINE.ORG

Research for Episode 56 includes:

⁠A Look Back at the Teenage 'Thrill Killer' Who Slit the Throat of a 9-Year-Old Girl | Investigation Discovery⁠

⁠Alyssa D. Bustamante, Appellant, v. State of Missouri, Respondent. (2015) | FindLaw⁠

⁠Alyssa Bustamante Interrogation Video⁠

⁠Alyssa Bustamante | Murderpedia, the encyclopedia of murderers⁠

⁠Alyssa Bustamante sentenced in child murder case - CSMonitor.com

⁠Diary of a 'thrill-kill': Missouri teen Alyssa Bustamante murders neighbor girl, records event in journal⁠

⁠Elizabeth-Olten-murder-Mother-sues-mental-health-clinic-Missouri-teen-killed-daughter⁠

⁠Evidence in Bustamante case detailed⁠

⁠Journal helps police find a 2009 Missouri teen thrill killer⁠

⁠Judge Grants Motion to Suppress Evidence in Bustamante Case | Fulton Sun⁠

⁠Petition · Repeal Law That Could Free Elizabeth Olten's Murderer Alyssa Bustamante Within 3 Years - United States · Change.org

⁠Prosecutor: Alyssa Bustamante Killed Elizabeth Olten Because "She Wanted to Know What it Felt Like" - CBS ⁠

⁠Teen killer had troubled family⁠